http://mises.org/etexts/classical.pdf
I found this article about democracy. I know that my week is not until April, but I thought this might help some of us understand where Dewey is coming from and where his thoughts on democracy find their home. Even if you just read the first page, you will know Dewey a little better. Yes, he is an optimist and that is why I like him. The original plan for American Democracy has failed to live up to the originators expectations and we are left to pick up the pieces and wonder why our legal, social, and education systems are failing. Think about your active part in the community. Think about your active part in our democracy. Are you taking your job of being "the people" seriously or are you complacent like most of middle class America? I will be honest. I cry every time I hear our National Anthem play. Heck, I am tearing up right now thinking about it. Laugh, its okay. I laugh at myself too. But we do live in a country that is famous for its radical thoughts and actions in the past centuries. However, we have not been radical as a people, for a very long time. Dewey would be outraged and writing every day about the state of affairs of our nation. I will hop off of my soap box for today. Thanks for laughing with me.... Billie
Friday, February 26, 2010
Thursday, February 25, 2010
The Hobart Shakespeareans
Rafe Esquith became famous due to his Shakespeare program, which has attracted some acting luminaries:
There are plenty of other Esquith videos on YouTube!
There are plenty of other Esquith videos on YouTube!
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
Rafe Esquith Links:
All-
I know Dr. Pope will post more about Esquith's book, Teaching Like Your Hair's On Fire: The Methods and Madness Inside Room 56,but I had heard of this book before on NPR. Below are links to an article/book excerpt and a 7 minute interview. As we said at the end of class, it's tough trying to find your place as a teacher/artist/mediator with all of the state/federal mandates that can, at times, stymie creative approaches.
As a former 5th grade humanities teacher, I concur with Esquith's teaching methodologies - inspire your students by exposing them to a varied and advanced curriculum that challenges them and you as a teacher. And going back to Dewey, I don't think reflective practices are considered enough by teachers with regard to their teaching and ways to refine their practices. On my 5th grade team, my mentor would always tell me, "Why re-invent the wheel, Lauren?" Well, sometimes we need to break out of old methods that simply aren't working. Teaching is hard work and while the courses we are taking and the materials we are learning are so beneficial, there's nothing like your first week/month/year in the classroom. I have many, many stories! Sadly, from some of my experiences, teachers are often burned out after 5-10 years in the profession. It's refreshing to see folks like Esquith who have such a sustained passion and love of teaching. I'd encourage you to listen.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=6939776
Interview: http://www.npr.org/templates/player/mediaPlayer.html?action=1&t=1&islist=false&id=6939776&m=6939842
Lauren
I know Dr. Pope will post more about Esquith's book, Teaching Like Your Hair's On Fire: The Methods and Madness Inside Room 56,but I had heard of this book before on NPR. Below are links to an article/book excerpt and a 7 minute interview. As we said at the end of class, it's tough trying to find your place as a teacher/artist/mediator with all of the state/federal mandates that can, at times, stymie creative approaches.
As a former 5th grade humanities teacher, I concur with Esquith's teaching methodologies - inspire your students by exposing them to a varied and advanced curriculum that challenges them and you as a teacher. And going back to Dewey, I don't think reflective practices are considered enough by teachers with regard to their teaching and ways to refine their practices. On my 5th grade team, my mentor would always tell me, "Why re-invent the wheel, Lauren?" Well, sometimes we need to break out of old methods that simply aren't working. Teaching is hard work and while the courses we are taking and the materials we are learning are so beneficial, there's nothing like your first week/month/year in the classroom. I have many, many stories! Sadly, from some of my experiences, teachers are often burned out after 5-10 years in the profession. It's refreshing to see folks like Esquith who have such a sustained passion and love of teaching. I'd encourage you to listen.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=6939776
Interview: http://www.npr.org/templates/player/mediaPlayer.html?action=1&t=1&islist=false&id=6939776&m=6939842
Lauren
A Little Thought on The Reading
Since I will not be in class to discuss I thought I would just put some input on here, even though my input in class is sometimes not that much and this article in Dewey was tougher than they have been lately, but I am going to refer to this question and expand upon it somewhat.
Dewey-On page 357 2/3rds of the way down the 1st column, Dewey said that “Justice Holmes has generalized the situation by saying that the whole outline of the law is the resultant of a conflict at every point between logic and good sense”. Do you agree? Why or why not?
I agree with this statement of Dewey, because when we talk about law and logic it is hard to draw that line between the two, what may seem logical in a situation may not be the correct law to follow. It is somewhat related to morals and ethics when you start speaking of logic, but if we keep going to page 359 where Dewey starts to talk about "Courts not only...until all the way until he says it will indicate a rule for dealing with similar cases in the future" (which is about in the middle of the 2nd column on that page). I agree that we do reach decisions in law based upon justifying reasons, even if we say somone commited murder, but cannot give enough reasons or evidence the person is most likely not convicted. I do like where he says we reach these decisions so that in other cases we have something to base it on. This relates back to the zero tolerance in a way because we don't give the children a basis or a reasoning, which Dewey suggest that we do need reasoning behind law, but even if we give a reasoning it may not always be logical. We know it would be logical to find a murder that says they killed someone guilty, but without enough reasoning we cannot find them truly guilty. I hope that makes sense. I did find this section a little difficult because it is hard to take logic, and law seperately, becuse they are so closely related. I do like how I now see where all our other class discussions are falling together with the teaching in the democracy because this article puts us more back to laws, and the fact that laws cannot be broken, but justifying even the law may not always be logical. Sorry I missed the discussion, but this was some of my input in it!
Hayley
Dewey-On page 357 2/3rds of the way down the 1st column, Dewey said that “Justice Holmes has generalized the situation by saying that the whole outline of the law is the resultant of a conflict at every point between logic and good sense”. Do you agree? Why or why not?
I agree with this statement of Dewey, because when we talk about law and logic it is hard to draw that line between the two, what may seem logical in a situation may not be the correct law to follow. It is somewhat related to morals and ethics when you start speaking of logic, but if we keep going to page 359 where Dewey starts to talk about "Courts not only...until all the way until he says it will indicate a rule for dealing with similar cases in the future" (which is about in the middle of the 2nd column on that page). I agree that we do reach decisions in law based upon justifying reasons, even if we say somone commited murder, but cannot give enough reasons or evidence the person is most likely not convicted. I do like where he says we reach these decisions so that in other cases we have something to base it on. This relates back to the zero tolerance in a way because we don't give the children a basis or a reasoning, which Dewey suggest that we do need reasoning behind law, but even if we give a reasoning it may not always be logical. We know it would be logical to find a murder that says they killed someone guilty, but without enough reasoning we cannot find them truly guilty. I hope that makes sense. I did find this section a little difficult because it is hard to take logic, and law seperately, becuse they are so closely related. I do like how I now see where all our other class discussions are falling together with the teaching in the democracy because this article puts us more back to laws, and the fact that laws cannot be broken, but justifying even the law may not always be logical. Sorry I missed the discussion, but this was some of my input in it!
Hayley
Logic vs. "Common Sense" as seen through "The Big Bang Theory"
This is a clip I found that I thought relates to the Dewey reading and the idea that many who are full of logic, lack the idea of "common sense." In this clip one of the scientists from the show who is socially awkward believes he found an algorithm to making friends. Enjoy!
Tuesday, February 23, 2010
Outline for "Logical Method and the Law"
This week's essay is, I think, one of the more difficult (sorry George!). So here's a brief outline of what I intend to talk about during class tomorrow. I'll work it in and around our discussion and come back to it at the end; hold me to this if something doesn't get covered to your satisfaction.
Dewey's Dichotomy: Logic vs. "Common Sense"
1. Logic (Standard View)
Dewey's Dichotomy: Logic vs. "Common Sense"
1. Logic (Standard View)
- Universals/Principals/Major Premises
- Particulars/Facts/Minor Premises
- Conclusion
- Universals
- Particulars
- Conclusion
- Inquiry
- Judgment & Justification
- Are teachers technicians? Judges? Experts?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)