Showing posts with label music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label music. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Bloom and Music

In his book, The Closing of the American Mind, Allan Bloom makes the statement that classics ( e.g., music and literature) are good, all else, not so much. He condemns the entire film genre and we can assume television as well, as not good. I agree that classic works have a theme and complexity to them that is lacking in many modern artistic works, however I disagree with the assumption that what is not classic is not good. I recognize that these modern works are not going to go away until they are replaced by something that in Bloom's view would be even worse. As future teachers, it will be important for us to relate the classic works to our students in ways that are relevant and engaging. So as bad as Bloom says these modern works are, they can be used as a portal for teachers to bring the classics to their students. I think this gets to the heart of Bloom's statement in the Preface of the book that "No real teacher can doubt that his task is to assist his pupil to fulfill human nature against all the deforming forces of convention and prejudice".

As teachers we can bring our students to recognize the classics they know through pop culture. By revealing the classics in the movies, television shows and cartoons watched by students, teachers can draw students into study and discussion of classic works. Consider the final movement, the Ode to Joy, in Beethoven's Symphony No. 9 in D Minor. This music can be appreciated on its own by some, or through the revelation that it is used in the movies A Clockwork Orange and Die Hard. Perhaps film clips can be shared in class to see if students could identify the music. Who among us can hear Rossini's The Barber of Seville Overture without picturing Bugs Bunny massaging the scalp of Elmer Fudd in that famous cartoon? This draws us into the fond rememberance of time spent at the movies with friends or perhaps of time spent in front of the television in our youth while our mothers were busy in the kitchen frying up bacon and eggs for the family breakfast. By drawing our senses and emotions into the discussion of the classics, students can develop a more passionate relationship and appreciation for the classic arts.

There are several websites devoted to helping folks make these connections - here are just a few entertaining sites:

For classical music in movies, see: http://classicalmusic.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?zi=1/XJ/Ya&sdn=classicalmusic&cdn=entertainment&tm=29&gps=60_469_935_635&f=00&tt=14&bt=1&bts=1&zu=http%3A//www.classicalarchives.com/movies/

For classical music in television, see: http://classicalmusic.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?zi=1/XJ/Ya&sdn=classicalmusic&cdn=entertainment&tm=256&gps=84_523_935_635&f=00&tt=14&bt=1&bts=1&zu=http%3A//www.geocities.com/musiclassical/themes.html

To learn all about the most popular classical music used in pop culture, see: http://www.kickassclassical.com/

As effective teachers we need to be open to use all the tools at our disposal in the education of our students, and pop culture can certainly be one of those tools. Teachers can use modern music and films to elicit emotion and experiences that our students can relate to, allowing us to create a bridge to the classics. So while Bloom may say modern works are not good, I maintain that they serve a good purpose and are therefore worthwhile.

Tuesday, February 5, 2008

Bloom and Television's influence

When I was in the fourth grade, my dad announced, somewhat out of the blue, that he was going to, as he put it, “Throw out all the damn TVs.” My brother and sisters and I took this as just another one of his many empty threats, until the Goodwill truck appeared and an evil looking man with big, sausage arms carried the color TVs out of our house and onto his truck and drove away. My mom said we cried more that day than the time they told us they were getting rid of the cat. Maybe my parents had hopes that we would fill our leisure with loftier pursuits, like reading great works of literature and listening to classical music. That was not the case. One might argue, as Bloom suggests, that it was too late; pop culture had already burled its way through our brains causing extensive and irreparable damage.

Four years after the TVs were banished from our home, my brother, Marty, was born. Marty was never exposed to T.V. in the home. I remember the day he came home from my grandparents’ house and with big, round toddler eyes filled with innocence and wonder asked my parents if they could buy one of those boxes with the moving pictures inside. Poor kid. As Bloom would expect, without the distraction of television, Marty turned out to be a voracious reader. He was crazy about books. He coveted them and collected them and carried them everywhere. But his book collection didn’t include Plato, Shakespeare, and Balzac. He read Tom Clancy, and Raymond Chandler, and Ken Follett, that is, after my mother had ripped out the two or three pages in the middle of the book – the requisite steamy sex scene – that she claimed had nothing to do with the book and everything to do with book sales. Perhaps Marty preferred these modern writers because these were the authors my parents were reading. Maybe he would have chosen the “great” writers if he had been more exposed to them. From my own experience, after having been forced to read Beowulf, anything touted as a “great work of literature” made me highly suspicious; that is, until I took a Russian History class in high school. We were told to select a book by one of the Russian authors. It was our choice. I researched several books before choosing Anna Karenina. I can truthfully say that I really enjoyed most of the book.

Maybe it’s the way great works of literature and classical music is typically presented to us that makes most of us recoil. Maybe it’s the way guys like Bloom make us feel vulgar and stupid for not having an immediate appreciation for classical literature and music that turns us off. I agree that children should be exposed to literature and classical music, but it should be presented in a positive manner. Children should feel free to express their opinions about the works, both positive and negative. A more open approach to the classics might encourage children to pursue reading, classical, and other types of music for both enlightenment and pleasure. After all, it ultimately is the reader or listener who determines what is or what is not to be a classic.